Government Finance and Operations 03/08/2013
Every year, the Legislature introduces a number of bills that
would affect the sales and use taxes; many of them would grant
exemptions from the tax, others would expand or shrink the base.
This year is no exception.
What is different this year is the importance of the sales and
use taxes to counties. Counties have for decades received a penny
of the sales tax generated in unincorporated areas, called the
Bradley-Burns, and since the 1990s, counties have received a
half-cent for 1991 Realignment and most of another half-cent for
Proposition 172 public safety services. There’s another
quarter-cent that funds county transportation activities (some
counties have raised the self-help portion of the sales tax to
increase this amount). But now counties also receive 1.0625 cents
for 2011 Realignment.
Add all those pennies add up, and of the base sales tax rate
of 7.5 percent, county shares account for as much as 3.3125, or
just under 45 percent of the revenue, depending on where the sale
takes place.
With that in mind, CSAC will be keeping a close eye on proposed
exemptions and other changes to sales tax law. Below is a list of
the bills introduced this year on the subject. A few others are
out there too, but are only spot bills to this point. If they are
amended to include substantial changes, you’ll find them here.
Sales and Use Taxes
AB 143 (Holden) – Watch
As Amended on March 4, 2013
AB 143, by Assembly Member Chris Holden, would exempt from use
taxes, but not sales taxes, purchases made by members of the
military, reserve, and national guard who bought the items before
the reporting date on their orders transferring them to
California, which seems only fair. It does not include aircraft,
vehicles, or vessels.
The Assembly Revenue and Taxation Committee will consider AB 143
at its hearing on April 1, 2013.
AB 479 (Donnelly) – Oppose Unless Amended
As Introduced on February 19, 2013
AB 479, by Assembly Member Tim Donnelly, would exempt from sales
and use taxes textbooks sold to a student at a college or by
someone whose primary purposes is selling textbooks to college
students. “Textbook” includes any book directed or recommended by
an instructor for use as a basis for a course. It does not
include CDs or other electronic media. The bill does not except
any of the local shares from the exemption. As with so many other
tax exemptions affecting local revenue, if the state prioritizes
the sorts of purchases contemplated in this bill, it should use
state funds to do so or reimburse counties for their losses.
The Assembly Revenue and Taxation Committee will consider AB 479
at its hearing on April 1, 2013.
AB 718 (Melendez) – Oppose Unless Amended
As Introduced on February 21, 2013
AB 718, by Assembly Member Melissa Melendez, would make April 15
a sales tax holiday, though it would not apply to the use tax.
The bill does except from the exemption the Bradley-Burns, but
not any of the other shares that benefit counties. If the state
prioritizes purchases made on this day as opposed to other days,
it should use state funds to do so or reimburse counties for
their losses.
The Assembly Revenue and Taxation Committee will consider AB 718
at its hearing on April 15, 2013, fittingly enough.
AB 575 (V. Manuel Pérez) – Pending
As Introduced on February 20, 2013
AB 575, by Assembly Member V. Manuel Pérez, would specifically
extend sales and use taxes to include the sale of counterfeit and
pirated material. Doing so would heap penalties on sellers who
engage in these activities, making them liable for any sales tax
they failed to collect or remit on the illegal merchandise, as
well as penalties and interest.
The Assembly Revenue and Taxation Committee will consider AB 575
at its hearing on April 1, 2013.
AB 798 (Wagner) – Request for Comment
As Introduced on February 21, 2013
AB 798, by Assembly Member Don Wagner, would remove the section
stating that anyone who makes sales two times or less per year
period does not count as a retailer who has to collect sales tax.
However, the bill expands the “occasional sale” exemption to
include sales paid with something other than money (barter) worth
less than $2,000, or, if worth more than $2,000, are fewer than
twelve in any twelve-month period. This only applies to the sale
of property a seller has or uses not in the course of the
activities for which they’re required to hold a seller’s
permit.
The Assembly Revenue and Taxation Committee will consider AB 798
at its hearing on April 1, 2013.
AB 799 (Wagner) – Request for Comment
As Introduced on February 21, 2013
AB 799, by Assembly Member Don Wagner, is just like AB 798, but
without the barter aspect. In other words, sellers would be able
to make as many sales under $2,000 as they like without charging
sales tax, as long as they are sales of property they don’t have
or use in their usual course of business, the business for which
they are required to hold a seller’s permit. And they could make
up to eleven sales per year of as much money as they like without
charging sales tax.
The Assembly Revenue and Taxation Committee will consider AB 798
at its hearing on April 15, 2013.
AB 163 (Atkins) – Watch
As Introduced on January 23, 2013
AB 163, by Assembly Member Toni Atkins, would delete the 2014
sunset on the exemption for on-base thrift stores operated by
military welfare societies. The bill is not currently set for
hearing.
AB 486 (Mullin) – Pending
As Introduced on February 19, 2013
AB 486, by Assembly Member Kevin Mullin, would exempt property
bought for use in the manufacturing process or a manufacturer’s
research and development. The bill excepts the Bradley-Burns
portion of the sales tax, but not the other portions that benefit
counties. It is not currently set for hearing.
AB 1077 (Muratsuchi) – Oppose Unless Amended
As Introduced on February 22, 2013
AB 1077, by Assembly Member Al Murastsuchi, would exempt the
incremental price difference between an alternative fuel vehicle
and a comparable regular fuel vehicle until 2022. Importantly, it
also reduces the Vehicle License Fee by the incremental cost. VLF
entirely benefits counties as part of 2011 Realignment. The bill
excepts the Bradley-Burns portion of the sales tax, but not the
other portions that benefit counties. It is not currently set for
hearing.
AB 1326 (Gorell) – Oppose Unless Amended
As Introduced on February 22, 2013
AB 1326, by Assembly Member Jeff Gorell, would exempt, until
2024, property used to manufacture unmanned aerial vehicles. The
bill also provides income and corporation taxes credits for wages
paid, declining every two years. The bill does not except any
portion of the sales tax that benefit counties. It is not
currently set for hearing.
SB 19 (Knight) – Oppose Unless Amended
As Introduced on December 3, 2012
SB 19, by Senator Steve Knight, would exempt property used to
construct, reconstruct, or improve facilities for launching or
manufacturing equipment used to renovate, rehabilitate, or
reconstruct commercial space launch sites. Property capable of
space flight, property used aboard space vehicles, and fuel for
space flight are already exempt. The bill does not except any
portion of the sales tax that benefit counties. It is not
currently set for hearing.
SB 235 (Wyland) – Pending
As Introduced on February 12, 2013
SB 235, by Senator Mark Wyland, would exempt property used
primarily for manufacturing or for a manufacturer’s research and
development. The bill not only excepts the Bradley-Burns and 2011
Realignment from its provisions, it also excepts 1991
Realignment, the triple-flip, Proposition 172, and even the
quarter-cent raised by Proposition 30. It is not currently set
for hearing.
SB 412 (Knight) – Pending
As Introduced on February 20, 2013
SB 412, by Senator Steve Knight, would exempt property used to
manufacture aerospace products or related research and
development or maintenance and repair of that property. Like SB
235, the bill not only excepts the Bradley-Burns and 2011
Realignment from its provisions, it also excepts 1991
Realignment, the triple-flip, Proposition 172, and the
quarter-cent raised by Proposition 30. It is not currently set
for hearing.
SB 732 (Berryhill) – Oppose Unless Amended
As Introduced on February 22, 2013
SB 732, by Senator Tom Berryhill, would subtract the value of a
trade-in vehicle from the purchase price of a new vehicle,
including a motorcycle, for the purposes of calculating the sales
tax. The bill does not except any portion of the sales tax that
benefit counties. It is not currently set for hearing.
AB 781 (Bocanegra) – Support
As Introduced on February 21, 2013
AB 781, by Assembly Member Raul Bocanegra, would create a felony
for selling, buying, installing, or possessing software that
falsifies electronic cash register data. Such software is
designed so that the retailer charges the customer the sales tax
and then keeps it, by hiding true sales amounts. The bill is not
currently set for hearing.
AB 919 (Williams) – Watch
As Introduced on February 22, 2013
AB 919, by Assembly Member Das Williams, would repay itinerate
vendors who are veterans and did not collect sales tax from their
customers between 2002 and 2010 but were made to pay the amount
they should have charged plus interest and penalties. The
veterans relied on an incorrect, but reasonable, interpretation
of state law when not charging sales tax. The bill is not
currently set for hearing.
AB 1049 (Harkey) – Request for Comment
As Introduced on February 22, 2013
AB 1049, by Assembly Member Diane Harkey, would change the way
interest on tax overpayments is determined to match the way
interest on underpayments is determined. The bill amends a
section of sales tax law that many other taxes and fees include
by reference. It would appear to make it profitable, in some
cases, for taxpayers to indefinitely delay paying their taxes.
The bill is not currently set for hearing.
AB 1203 (Gorell) – Watch
As Introduced on February 22, 2013
AB 1203, by Assembly Member Jeff Gorell, would disallow penalty
and interest charges for sales, use, income, and corporation
taxes unpaid because the taxpayer relied on a statute the courts
later struck down as unconstitutional. The taxpayer would have to
pay within 60 days of a new notice. The bill is not currently set
for hearing.
SB 323 (Lara) – Watch
As Introduced on February 19, 2013
SB 323, by Senator Ricardo Lara, would remove exemption of sales,
use, and corporation taxes for public charity youth organizations
that discriminate on the basis of gender identity, race, sexual
orientation, nationality, religion, or religious affiliation. The
bill is not currently set for hearing.